What are the Best Islands in the Bahamas?

Published October 17, 2023

Whatever island you visit in The Bahamas, you’ll be wowed by the stunning scenery, delicious cuisine, and exhilarating nightlife. 

Couples, in particular, have many date options; whether they want to do something romantic or something relaxing, the possibilities are endless. If you’re looking for the best island in The Bahamas for your next trip, we did the homework for you so you won’t have to!

The Best Islands In The Bahamas

Looking for the best places to visit in The Bahamas with your loved ones? Below are the best options we found that you may just fall in love with: 

1. Staniel Cay

There are less than 118 permanent residents on this tiny island; thus, it offers ultimate solitude. It is no secret that Staniel Cay is the ideal island in the Bahamas for honeymooners looking for ultimate tranquility.

Newlyweds will appreciate the privacy of the beach property and the opportunity to cool off in the ocean. However, several options are available if you’re looking for a more active vacation in The Bahamas! 

Snorkeling the nearby coral reefs is fantastic, and a trip to nearby Pig Beach and Thunderball Grotto is a must. Reserve a seat at the Staniel Cay Marina restaurant for a date night with that special someone!

2. Paradise Island

Paradise Island is the best island in The Bahamas for couples if you’ve never been to a tropical vacation spot before and want the whole tourist experience! 

Here, there are a variety of excursions available in Nassau, the island’s capital city, including shark swimming and helicopter tours to take in the crystal-clear waters surrounding the island. You may relax by the pool or go on an exhilarating parasailing trip as a couple, but this vibrant island will never leave you bored!

Also, don’t forget to try the delectable cuisine on Paradise Island! It has conventional American food but pales compared to the island’s daily fresh seafood catch.

3. Crooked Island

Crooked Island, Acklins, Long Cay, and Castle Island are all favorites among wildlife enthusiasts in the Bahamas. Turtles and pink flamingos abound on the area’s uninhabited beaches, lined with soft, white sand. In addition, bat caves can be found all around the island, and they are well worth exploring if you’re down for a very exciting and scary challenge!

These islands have it all: peace and quiet, as well as many exciting things to do. In this secluded part of the Bahamas, you can have a romantic break and an exploratory adventure on one of the island’s many animal expeditions and water destinations.

4. Cat Island

Cat Island has a low tourist density, so it’s a good choice if you’re looking for a quiet vacation. 

It should be on your list of the best Bahamas islands for couples if you want a holiday away from the crowds. It has pink sand beaches, unusual flora & fauna, including island birds, sharks, and cultural museums. It will tug at your heartstrings with its original island melody and have you coming back for more!

5. Green Turtle Cay

There is a lot to see and do on this island! It can only be reached by boat, so plan on making a pit stop along the way. However, the landscape is well worth the diversion.

As the best island in the Bahamas for couples, Green Turtle Cay deserves to be featured because of its picturesque New England-style architecture, pristine waters, and numerous exciting and romantic activities. 

So, in the company of your beloved, you can have a romantic snorkeling trip with sea turtles while listening to the lapping waves. This is one of those islands where you just can’t go wrong.

6. Bimini

Located just 50 miles off the coast of Miami, the westernmost part of the Bahamas. Bimini is known for its crystal-clear turquoise waters and vibrant marine life.

It’s a popular destination for snorkeling, scuba diving, and fishing enthusiasts. Bimini is also rich in history, connecting to famous figures like Ernest Hemingway.

7. Great Exuma

Great Exuma is part of the Exuma Cays. It is a stunning archipelago known for its pristine beaches and vibrant coral reefs. The island offers a range of activities.

From swimming with pigs at Pig Beach to exploring the famous Thunderball Grotto, a natural cave featured in James Bond films. Great Exuma is a paradise for water sports lovers.

8. San Salvador Island

San Salvador is the perfect choice if you’re looking for a secluded and serene getaway. With its untouched beaches and spectacular diving spots, this island offers a peaceful retreat. It’s also rich in history, as it is believed to be the first landfall of Christopher Columbus in the New World.

9. Andros

Known as the “Bonefishing Capital of the World,” Andros is a haven for anglers. This vast island has many blue holes, mangrove swamps, and national parks. This makes it a paradise for nature lovers. Andros also boasts stunning beaches, such as the famous Tiamo Beach.

10. Long Island

As the name suggests, Long Island stretches over 80 miles, offering diverse landscapes and attractions. Long Island has something for everyone, from tranquil white sand beaches to dramatic cliffs and caves.

Visitors can explore Dean’s Blue Hole. This is one of the world’s deepest underwater sinkholes. Or they can visit historic landmarks like Hamilton’s Cave.